SEARCH - BEST SELLERS - BLOG - CONTACT US - CUSTOM ORDERS - HELP - HUGE DISCOUNTS - NEWSLETTER
Business Books & Great Ideas
My Account - Order History - Shopping Cart - Log In

October 16, 2006

Resisting Relevance

Filed under: Big Ideas — Tom Ehrenfeld @ 11:49 am
Tweet

Heres a terrific interview with Stanford University professor emeritus James March from the current issue of Harvard Business Review (this article is free online.) March is somewhat of the gurus guru, an intellectual whose work may be little-known but is deeply felt (i.e. he may not be famous but the key thinkers are influenced by him.)

In a fascinating interview concerning the applicability of models to work, the nature of trust, the need for foolishness, and other thoughts on how people think and learn, March shares a range of terrific morsels. He opens his classes by telling his students, I am not now, nor have I ever been, relevant, as a way of signaling them not to seek immediate usefulness from his ideas. If a manager asks an academic consultant what to do and that consultant answers, then the consultant should be fired, he explains. And then he shares thoughts that clearly have lasting impact.

For example, March discusses the hot-stove effectwhereby a cat that jumps on a hot stove will never repeat that mistake, yet will also avoid jumping on all stoves in the future.

The hot-stove effect is a fundamental problem of learning, he says. Learning reduces your likelihood of repeating things that got you in trouble, as you hope it will. But that means you know less about the domains where youve done poorly than about the domains where youve done well. You might say, Well, why should that cause problems? It causes problems whenever your early experience with an alternative is, for whatever reason, not characteristic of what subsequent experience would be. It clearly causes problems in domains where practice makes a difference. For example, you are likely to abandon an approach or technology prematurely.

There’s much much more here. Recommended reading!

Comments Off
  • http://twentypercenter.blogspot.com/ Max Leibman

    That interview looks like a great catch!
    I like the “hot-stove effect” (it’s much clearer than the “overgeneralization” we studied in my Learn ing & Motivation course).
    What I wonder about (and I’ll definitely give the interview and March’s work a closer look) is how best to tell whether a poor performance or experience is “not characteristic of what subsequent experience would be.” Avoiding our chronic weaknesses and building on strengths (the Gallup/Clifton/Buckingham approach) still strikes me as a powerful approach, but March (rightly) calls attention to the possibility that we may have mistaken a single bad experience for proof of weakness.





  • Categories
    • 100 Best (89)
    • Advertising (18)
    • Ask 8cr! (23)
    • Audio (115)
    • Bestsellers (4)
    • Big Ideas (145)
    • Blog (543)
    • Book Awards (71)
    • Book Reviews (196)
    • Careers (41)
    • ChangeThis (56)
    • Communication (80)
    • Current Events (83)
    • Customer Service (37)
    • Design (35)
    • Entrepreneurship (4)
    • Events (21)
    • Excerpts and Essays (335)
    • Fables (1)
    • Finance and Economics (82)
    • Friday Links (84)
    • General Business (187)
    • General Management (244)
    • Global Business (74)
    • Guest Post (7)
    • History and Biographies (96)
    • Human Resources/Organizational Development (98)
    • In the Books (4)
    • InBubbleWrap (23)
    • Information Technology (69)
    • Innovation (109)
    • International Bestsellers (28)
    • Internet (21)
    • Interviews (13)
    • Jack Covert Selects (588)
    • Jack's Thoughts (38)
    • Leadership (153)
    • Lists (164)
    • Marketing (290)
    • Misc. (286)
    • New Releases (28)
    • Newsletter (2)
    • Personal Development (181)
    • Personal Finance and Investing (41)
    • Presentations (1)
    • Public Relations (7)
    • Publishing Industry (176)
    • Quotations (104)
    • Retail (18)
    • Safety, Health, and Wellness (14)
    • Sales (64)
    • Small Business (49)
    • Social Responsibilty (39)
    • Start-ups (76)
    • Strategy (88)
    • Technology (7)
    • The 100 Best (13)
    • The Company (140)
    • Thought Leaders (18)
    • Training and Development (12)
    • Uncategorized (568)
  • Meta
    • Log in
    • Entries RSS
    • Comments RSS
    • WordPress.org



 
800 CEO Read - Daily Blog - 100 Best Business Books -
© 800-CEO-READ (800)-236-7323